When Faith Winters returns to Chestnut Grove, Virginia, for the community's annual Christmas celebration, she's determined to make amends. She's failed at making it on Broadway and is certain everyone hates her for decisions she had no control over.

Jake Whitmire is the sheriff in Chestnut Grove, but keeping the area free of crime is the least of his worries. Most days are filled with trying to keep the community's spirits up as jobs have disappeared. He never expected to see the woman who broke his heart return home to lead up the town's Christmas concert, nor is he sure he can ever forgive her.

As someone in town begins sabotaging the community's celebration, Faith and Jake work together to find the person responsible and ensure their friend Jenny's last request is fulfilled. Can holiday hope heal the broken spirit afflicting Chestnut Grove residents? Or is it time for everyone--including Faith and Jake--to treasure the memories of the past but to move on?